I think that is something the community still needs to work on.


What was supposed to be a slam dunk for nontheists has become a slap in the face after a petition on behalf of a jailed Indonesian atheist failed to attract even one-third of the signatures it needed to gain White House attention.

The petition was launched last month by The Center for Inquiry, a humanist organization, on We The People, a government website designed to bring grass roots efforts to the attention of the White House. Petitions must garner 25,000 signatures within 30 days in to secure a government response.

The petition called for the Obama Administration to pressure the Indonesian government to free Alexander Aan, who was arrested for the criminal offense of expressing his unbelief online. The petition garnered about 8,000 signatures when it expired Thursday (Aug 16).

That failure has left many atheists, humanists, skeptics and other nonbelievers scratching their heads. If, as they believe, their community has grown in numbers, strength and organization in the last decade, why didn’t more people sign the petition?

“It didn’t fail for lack of effort,” said Michael De Dora, CFI’s director of government affairs, the author of the petition and its first signatory. “So there is a sense of confusion right now internally about why this failed.”


The petition’s failure has exposed another paradox of the nontheist community. In recent years, it has made an organized effort to promote its members as compassionate, caring and concerned about justice. The unofficial motto “Good without God” has been used to rally support for charitable organizations, food banks and blood drives, services for the homeless and disaster relief efforts.

“It is one thing to talk about ‘Good without God’ and have panel discussions about secular ethics, but it is quite another to take all that and make it part of your moral fiber and make a habit of doing good,” De Dora said. “I think that is something the community still needs to work on.”

This entry was posted in New Atheism and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to I think that is something the community still needs to work on.

  1. Wonders for Oyarsa says:

    I bit of an oversight, I suppose, but a bit of effort should clear that one up pretty quick. It’s not like the cultivation of virtue in a community has proven to be a difficult thing or anything. I’m sure Dawkins and the like will have that tackled in a jiffy. After all, they have the near monopoly of the world’s reason at their disposal, as well as all the benefits of modern science.

    “You’re that smart?”
    “Let me put it this way. Did you ever hear of Aristotle? Plato? Socrates?”

  2. Zia says:

    Even as a theist, it seems wrong to me that the individual was jailed for professing his unbelief.

    However the fact that the petition failed to get of the ground is interesting.

  3. My hypothesis is: they made the mistake of trying it in the summer, and summer is the Season of Internecine Warfare for the Gnus…

  4. Michael says:


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.