Atheist Wars Getting Hotter

I think it is becoming more clear how the recent flare up in the atheist wars is going to play out.  The social justice atheists are using the Buzzfeed article to systematically deplatform Lawrence Krauss.  I think their objective is to ultimately ban Krauss from the atheist/skeptic movement.  The problem is that Krauss has deep connections in the atheist movement – people like Richard Dawkins and Sam Harris.  What the social justice atheists will demand is that these skeptics, and all skeptic/atheist organizations, cease from promoting Lawrence Krauss.

We’ve already seen one such example:

“As the President of Secular Woman, it is my responsibility to urge [CFI] to prioritize the safety of women over whatever benefit they see in the continued attachment to Lawrence Krauss,” Monette Richards, who is a chapter leader of CFI Northeast Ohio, told Gizmodo. “This article has given them an excellent opportunity: make a break from past leadership practices; remove Krauss from their honorary board; promise to stop inviting him to events.”

“I certainly hope they don’t intend to ignore it and hope everyone forgets,” Richards added. “Because I will work hard to make sure no one does.”

So a hot button issue is going to be whether the CFI/RDF continue to promote Krauss.

We are also starting to see demands such as these:

 

Advertisements
This entry was posted in atheist activism, atheist wars, New Atheism, Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Atheist Wars Getting Hotter

  1. Mark Plus says:

    The movement atheists wouldn’t have these ridiculous problems if they just held sex-segregated conferences.

  2. TFBW says:

    Ah, I was wondering if the upcoming “Think Inc.” Dawkins/Krauss tour might attract some attention for de-platforming purposes. That’s an Australia/New Zealand tour scheduled to happen in May. These Social Justice types are causing event organisers a world of hurt. I expect atheism-based events to have flat-lined by the end of the year. We’ve already seen a rash of cancellations due to dwindling interest and/or lack of organiser competence. Sam Harris can probably keep doing his own personal chat circuit for now, but the drought is looking fairly severe elsewhere.

  3. Crude says:

    I’m putting my money on the SJW atheists. The Atheism+ schism has led to an exodus and further fragmenting of the atheist community, and the old guard is down to the incredibly irrelevant PZ Myers, the old and washed up Dawkins, and the energetic but spiraling-out-of-this Dawkins. Not sure what Jerry Coyne even does anymore.

    I think Krauss is done.

  4. Crude says:

    Pardon – energetic bu spiraling-out-of-this Harris. He seems to want to run in different circles now.

  5. TFBW says:

    @Crude: “[Harris] seems to want to run in different circles now.” I’d consider that a wise move, if true. Distance is the only defence.

  6. Michael says:

    Hmmm. Dawkins tweeted this today:

    The Origins Project at Arizona State University is one of the world’s most inspiring initiatives in the Culture of Science. I look forward to the 10th Anniversary celebration conference: https://t.co/kKocJ1wjXX— Richard Dawkins (@RichardDawkins) 25 February 2018

    Clever. By simply promoting Krauss’s baby after the Buzzfeeding frenzy, I’d say Dawkins is giving the middle finger to the feminists/social justice atheists. But he’s doing it in a way that while they will see it, the mainstream media will not. I’d say the odds of Dawkins dissociating himself from Krauss have grown remarkably low. Unless there is something more to come that the Buzzfeed story, look for Dawkins and Krauss to be doing their show.

  7. TFBW says:

    Dawkins has been well-invested in Krauss for a long time. He’s not going to ditch Krauss on the basis of shifting public opinion. In any case, I’m not sure that Dawkins realises how much of his atheist base is on board with Social Mob Justice. I doubt he has much appreciation for how hard they can hit his operation, despite his having been de-platformed before. It will be amusing indeed if the Krauss toxicity rubs off on Dawkins, and then entire organisations which bear the Dawkins imprimatur suddenly have to decide which side they are going to take. Buy popcorn now: the show could start at any minute.

  8. Dhay says:

    Phil Torres’ “Here are what some folks are saying about the recent allegations against Lawrence Krauss” has a long list of quotes of people saying (paraphrased) ‘we all knew about it all along’.

    Torres is still collecting quotes: “I will be adding to this list in the coming days.”

    View at Medium.com

  9. Dhay says:

    Darned https prefixes. Either click on the larger words or on:
    http://www.medium.com/@philosophytorres/here-are-what-some-folks-are-saying-about-the-recent-allegations-against-lawrence-krauss-e4c444b2d715

    *

    Clicking on the Phil Torres name showed up his review of Steven Pinker’s new book. The doom-and-gloom beware-everything-is-getting-worse apocalypse-soon Torres reviews the all-is-wonderful-and-everything-whatsoever-is-continually-getting-much-better Pinker.

    View at Medium.com

  10. Dhay says:

    > So a hot button issue is going to be whether the CFI/RDF continue to promote Krauss.

    Since an hour ago — ie approx 1435 GMT on 05 March 2018 — the CFI has displayed a Pinned Tweet saying:

    Richard Dawkins Foundation
    ‏Verified account @rdfrs
    1 hour ago

    Official Statement: The Center for Inquiry is committed to a policy (http://ow.ly/eaKH30iL3uS ) of zero-tolerance for sexual harassment. Serious allegations have been raised regarding Lawrence Krauss, and we suspend our association with him pending further information.

    http://www.twitter.com/rdfrs/status/970667788389019649

    It took a while, which indicates the CFI were reluctant, but they finally got around to taking provisional action.

  11. unclesporkums says:

    Another one bites the dust..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.